Smart switches compared: local control, Home Assistant and Matter

Prices: not tracked yet.

ProductWorks without the cloud?Local controlNeeds custom firmwareHome Assistant integrationHA IoT classHA quality scaleMatterPower monitoringMax loadConnectivityVersionsPrice
Shelly 1 Gen3Works without cloudYesNoShellyLocal pushplatinum—No16 AWi-FiEU—
Shelly 1PM Gen3Works without cloudYesNoShellyLocal pushplatinum—Yes16 AWi-FiEU—
TP-Link Kasa HS2004 catches to knowYesNoTP-Link Smart HomeLocal pollingplatinum——15 AWi-FiUS—
Inovelli Blue Series 2-1 Switch (VZM31-SN)Works without cloud3 catches to knowYesNoZigbee Home AutomationLocal polling——Yes—ZigbeeUS—

“—” means we haven't verified that value, not that the product lacks it. HA columns describe the Home Assistant integration as a whole, not this specific model; see each product page for details.

Order: Home Assistant integration quality scale (platinum first), then local push before local polling, then name.

Filtered lists